"My Boyfriend Charlie: Testimony of Margaret Bengsch Curtis, Collected by Oakley C. Johnson for a Biography of C.E. Ruthenberg, circa 1940." Edited transcription of the oral recollections of the childhood sweetheart of future Communist Party leader. Curtis remembers "Charlie" as an intelligent, neatly attired, bookish, and "sweet boy," who was "almost too bashful to kiss a girl." His mother, a kindly churchgoing homebody, spoke to C.E. around the house in the Low German dialect, but he always answered in English, Curtis recalls. At her 18th birthday party Curtis set C.E. up with his future wife, Rose, making sure that he took her home that night. Though Charlie and Rose later married, C.E. always carried a torch for her, Curtis remembers, although the sentiment was not returned. Neither she nor Rose were supportive of C.E.'s turn to radical politics, Curtis intimates.
"My Friend C.E. Ruthenberg: Testimony of Theodore E. Kretchmar, Collected by Oakley C. Johnson for a Biography of C.E. Ruthenberg, circa 1940." Short biographical sketch of CPUSA founding member and leader C.E. Ruthenberg by a boyhood friend who moved to New York City with Ruthenberg and worked with him at the Selmar-Hess Publishing Company there. Kretchmar describes Ruthenberg's father as a stern Prussian sort of man who ran an old fashioned beer saloon, his mother simple and sweet. "C.E." was bookish and an enthusiast for literature, poetry, drama, and philosophy who briefly aspired to the Lutheran ministry. After finishing Lutheran School at age 13 or 14, Ruthenberg enrolled straight away in business college, Kretchmar indicates, graduating at age 16 to take a job in the office of the Ohio Molding and Picture Frame Company. From there he moved to New York to take a job as a regional sales manager for the Selmar Hess Publishing Co, Kretchmar indicates. Originally a devotee of laissez faire when he came to New York, Ruthenberg was bested in a debate on socialism with a friend and co-worker, McBane Walker. Ruthenberg began reading Karl Marx's Capital to prepare himself for a future debate and wound up converting himself to the socialist cause.
"Memories of C.E. Ruthenberg by Israel Amter: Notes from an Interview Conducted by Oakley C. Johnson." [circa 1940]
This short memoir, previously an unpublished mass of handwritten
scrawl, adds substantially to the store of esoteric detail about the
seminal August 1922 raid upon the secret convention of the Communist
Party of America at Bridgman, Michigan. It was head of the "Technical
Department" L.E. Katterfeld who arranged the location of the gathering,
Amter notes, adding that he also arranged the successful 1920 secret
convention at the same place. Amter says he rode by train with stool
pigeon Francis Morrow and two others from Philadelphia to the
convention -- that en route Morrow stopped at a drugstore under the
pretext of purchasing medicine, going in alone, with a police tail
thereby apparently launched leading to the secret convention site near
Lake Michigan. With the convention approximately evenly divided between
pro-underground party "Geese" and anti-underground party
"Liquidationists," Amter reveals for the first time the discovery of a
secret "Center" faction including Liquidationist Jay Lovestone and
ostensible Geese Bert Wolfe and Herbert Benjamin. Based upon these
secret swing votes, "the Liquidators would have captured the convention
if not for the raid," the former Goose leader Amter declares. Alerted
to the forthcoming raid the previous evening, the convention's business
was quickly concluded and starting at midnight a stream of round trips
were made by car removing delegates in prioritized sequence. Amter
notes that he escapted with the last group to make it out at about 6 am
the morning of August 22. Ruthenberg's failure to leave in a very early
group is characterized as the "romantic" misstep of a leader with the
"psychology of a captain who wouldn't leave the ship till the last
sailor is out." Ruthenberg is characterized as a calm, dignified, and
widely respected leader -- "the force that held the Party together."
"Memories of C.E. Ruthenberg by Anna Damon: Excerpt from an Interview Conducted by Oakley C. Johnson, 1940."
Short memoir of the C.E. Ruthenberg collected from his party comrade
and common-law wife at the time of the Communist leader's death. Damon
offers exact details of Ruthenberg's fatal illness -- a chronicly
inflamed appendix which ruptured the night of Feb. 26/27, 1927. No
mention is made of heroic last words at the hospital (frequently quoted
in hagiographic recountings of his life in the party press). Rather
Ruthenbeg, given a final saline injection to revive him, "he just waved
his arm, several times, as if to encourage everyone." Ruthenberg is
characterized as a dedicated, modest, and economical man with an
affection for long walks in the country and detective stories. "He was
considered very stiff and correct but was a very fine human being.
You’d have a hard time getting close to him. But when you did, there
was the finest man! He said he built a fence around him to protect
himself. He had a fear of being hurt and being exploited by people,"
Damon recalls.
Damon, National Secretary of International Labor Defense at the time of
her death in 1944, indicates that she was the first Boston District
Organizer of the underground Communist Party of America -- a position
previously believed held by Antoinette Konikow.
"Memories of C.E. Ruthenberg by Charles Dirba: Excerpt from an Interview Conducted by Oakley C. Johnson, 1940."
Brief memoir of C.E. Ruthenberg collected by Oakley C. Johnson in 1940
for a biography which was finally published only in 1957. Dirba, a
former assistant to Ruthenberg, served as the Executive Secretary of
the parallel organization calling itself the Central Caucus during the
last part of 1921, remaining at that post until January 1922. Although
better qualified than any to shed light on that confusing period of
underground history, Dirba only acknowledges that "the Federation group
didn’t have much ground on which to stand," and that their attempt to
send John Ballam and an unnamed second individual to Moscow to change
the position of the Comintern was met only with "scolding." Dirba says
he refused to serve in an official capacity after the Comintern's views
were made clear but continued to pay dues to the dissident
organization, returning to the regular CPA only in the fall of 1922.
Ruthenberg is characterized as efficient and dedicated, more oriented
to detail work than a public leadership role, and a consistent adherent
of party unity.
"Memories of C.E. Ruthenberg by Bill Dunne: Excerpt from an Interview Conducted by Oakley C. Johnson, 1940."
This interview with William F. Dunne was collected for a biography of
C.E. Ruthenberg. Dunne, a factional opponent of Ruthenberg, makes no
pretense of having been an acolyte -- Ruthenberg is called "uninspired"
and "monstrously vain." "He was no scholar, he couldn't write — but he
was a gentleman. His relations with the Party were always very
formal.... He would become personally offended if he didn't get the
deference which he expected," Dunne recalls. Detail is given on the
exact location of the CPA's underground headquarters in early 1922 (an
apartment 11 St. Luke’s Place, New York City). Also interestingly
Dunne, with the benefit of hindsight, characterizes the Communist
Party's majority faction as being one of "Pepper and Lovestone." Dunne
declares: "Ruthenberg’s big mistake was to allow himself to be used by
the Lovestone caucus.... Pepper and Lovestone began caucusing and they
dragged Ruthenberg into it and made him their front man."
"Memories of C.E. Ruthenberg by M. Golos: Excerpt from an Interview Conducted by Oakley C. Johnson, 1940."
Memoir of C.E. Ruthenberg by CPA Russian Federationist M. Golos -- not
to be confused with Jacob "Red" Golos of Soviet espionage fame. Golos
provides esoteric detail regarding defense work in the aftermath of the
January 1920 raids and of the 1920 Ruthenberg faction spilt from the
Communist Party of America. With regard to the deportations, Golos
remarks: "Anybody who put up a fight wasn’t actually deported. Only
outstanding anarchists were deported whether they wanted to be or not.
Many wanted to be deported, however. They wanted to go back. So when
they were asked 'Are you for the overthrow of the U.S. government?'
they said, 'Yes.'" Golos points out that even factional opponents held
Ruthenberg with respect and calls him "a boss, a business man,
everything had to be just so when he was in the office."
"Memories of C.E. Ruthenberg by J.J. Ballam: Excerpt from an Interview Conducted by Oakley C. Johnson, June 3, 1940."
Fascinating unpublished memoir, previously a mass of handwritten
scrawl, by a feisty factionalist founder of the Communist Party of
America. Ballam relates details of Lenin's famous "Letter to American
Workers," which he says was delivered to him, addressed to Boston's
Latvian Branch No. 1 -- the nexus of the proto-Communist movement in
America, with which the non-Latvian Ballam was associated. "Pages were
lost," Ballam notes. In Ballam's view Ruthenberg was consistently
opposed to factionalism, refused to engage in gossip, and was driven to
work 18 hour days on behalf of the party. He is depicted as
straight-laced, rather stiff and dignified in bearing, an efficient
administrator, and an able extemporaneous speaker despite a monotone
delivery and an absence of rhetorical tricks. Ruthenberg's personal
relationship with William Z. Foster -- caricatured in the scholarly
literature as being a ceaseless and bitter factional opponent -- is
recalled as having been generally cordial, with Ruthenberg having
"accepted Foster from the beginning as a co-worker and accepted him as
the trade union leader." Ruthenberg's behavior during the raid on the
1922 Bridgman Convention is portrayed as courageous. Ballam emphasizes
a similarity of leadership style between Ruthenberg and Earl Browder.